← All articles

TL;DR

Choose Railway if: You want the fastest setup, the simplest UI, and don't mind that Paperclip-specific resources are bundled in one service. Railway's $20 free credit lets you try it without a credit card.

Choose Render if: You prefer more granular control over services (separate web service vs. background worker), or you're already using Render for other projects.

Pricing comparison

| | Railway | Render | |---|---|---| | Free tier | $5 credit/month (Hobby plan) | Free static sites; web services sleep | | Always-on minimum | $20/month (Pro plan) | $7/month (Starter web service) | | Free credit to start | $20 | None | | Persistent storage | $0.25/GB/month | $0.25/GB/month | | Bandwidth | $0.10/GB after 100 GB | Included in plan |

Winner on price: Railway for getting started (free $20 credit). Render for steady-state cost if you need always-on ($7/month vs Railway's $20/month Pro plan threshold for no sleep — though Railway Hobby includes some always-on behavior).

Setup experience

Railway:

• Connect GitHub repo → select Dockerfile or Nixpack → add environment variables → deploy
• Total time to live instance: 3–5 minutes
• Postgres plugin: add with one click, DATABASE_URL auto-injected
• No Dockerfile required for Node apps (Nixpack auto-detects)

Render:

• Create Web Service → connect GitHub → configure build/start commands → add persistent disk → deploy
• Total time: 5–10 minutes
• Postgres: separate managed database service, manually copy connection string
• More settings to configure upfront

Winner on setup: Railway.

Always-on behavior

For Paperclip, always-on is essential. Agents need to fire heartbeats on schedule — a sleeping instance misses runs.

Railway (Hobby plan, $5/month credit): Services can sleep after inactivity, but Railway gives you ways to configure this. Pro plan ($20/month) fully removes sleep.

Render (Free tier): Services sleep after 15 minutes of inactivity. This breaks Paperclip agent heartbeats. You must upgrade to the Starter plan ($7/month) for always-on.

Winner on always-on: Render (Starter plan) is cheaper for guaranteed always-on. Railway requires Pro for no sleep but gives you $20 free credit.

Persistent storage

Both Railway and Render support persistent volumes for Paperclip's data directory.

Railway: Add a Volume to your service, set the mount path, and it persists automatically. Managed, no configuration beyond mounting.

Render: Persistent Disk attached to your web service. Similar experience — configure size and mount path.

Both: $0.25/GB/month for storage.

Winner: Tie.

Performance

Both Railway and Render run on AWS infrastructure. Response times are comparable for typical Paperclip use.

Railway's regions: US West, US East, EU, Asia Pacific (and growing). Render's regions: Oregon, Ohio, Frankfurt, Singapore.

If you need a specific region (e.g., Sydney), check both providers — availability varies.

Winner: Tie for most users.

Developer experience

Railway:

• Clean, modern dashboard
• CLI (railway up, railway logs) is fast and well-designed
• Logs are real-time and easy to find
• GitHub integration is seamless

Render:

• More detailed service configuration options
• Good documentation
• Slightly more traditional "platform" feel
• Health checks and alerts are more configurable

Winner: Railway for simplicity. Render for more knobs to turn.

Deployment from code vs. image

Railway: Supports Git repos (Node, Python, etc. via Nixpacks) and Dockerfile. Auto-detects most setups.

Render: Supports Git repos and Dockerfile. Both require a Dockerfile for Node apps that aren't standard Express servers.

For Paperclip, you'll need a Dockerfile on both platforms since it's a custom Node app.

Support

Railway has good documentation and a Discord community. Render has documentation and a support email (slower response on free/Starter plans).

Neither offers phone support for developer-tier plans.

The recommendation

For hosting Paperclip:

1. Start with Railway — use the $20 free credit to test everything. If you stay below the Hobby plan threshold long-term, the cost difference is minimal.

2. Switch to Render if you need the $7/month always-on Starter plan and Railway's Hobby plan sleep behavior is causing issues.

Both platforms work well for Paperclip. Railway's onboarding is faster and the free credit makes it the default recommendation for getting started.

This is an independent guide. Paperclip Hosting is not affiliated with the official Paperclip project. Guide steps are based on real deployments and are subject to change as the software evolves.